Get a free Shopify store audit

Shopify Custom App vs Public App: Which One to Build?

Shopify custom apps and public apps differ in approval, billing, and revenue share. Here's how to pick the right one for your situation.

A Shopify custom app vs public app decision comes down to scope: a custom app is built for one merchant, needs no Shopify review, but can't charge that merchant through Shopify's billing system. A public app is built for many merchants, must pass review, and pays Shopify a share of its revenue. The real question is whether you're solving one store's problem or building a product to sell repeatedly.

Custom vs. Public: What Shopify's Own Rules Actually Say

Shopify's distribution rules draw a hard line between the two. A custom app installs on a single Shopify store, on multiple stores belonging to the same Plus organization, or on development stores, and needs no approval from Shopify before merchants can install it. A public app can be installed on multiple, unrelated Shopify stores, but it has to pass Shopify's app review first, and registering for the Shopify App Store carries a one-time fee. Once you pick a distribution method, you can't change it later, so this is a decision worth making deliberately rather than defaulting into.

The limitation that catches most merchants off guard: a custom app can't charge merchants through Shopify's app billing system. If you're building something you intend to charge for, that constraint alone often settles the decision in favor of public distribution, whatever else the app does.

These two models are what's left after Shopify phased out the alternatives. A third option — "Shopify admin" apps, built on a pre-generated Admin API access token — is no longer available for new apps, though existing ones keep working; they can't use App Bridge in the admin, can't use app extensions, and carry the same billing restriction as custom apps. Private apps, an older precursor to custom apps, were deprecated as of January 2022, and every remaining private app was automatically converted to a custom app as of January 20, 2023. Unpublished apps — public apps that skipped Shopify's review — were deprecated even earlier, as of December 9, 2019. What's left today is the clean two-way split: custom for one store, public for many, both going through Shopify's current review and billing rules rather than a legacy path.

Public apps themselves split one level further, into listed and unlisted. Both go through the same app review; the only difference is that an unlisted app doesn't appear in the Shopify App Store's search results or categories, so merchants only find it through a direct link.

When a single store's workflow doesn't match anything on the Shopify App Store, a scoped custom build is the direct answer — our Shopify app development team builds exactly to that store's process rather than adapting a generic public app to fit. Our walkthrough of building a Shopify app covers what that build process looks like from the Dev Dashboard onward.

What Going Public Actually Costs in Revenue Share

Registering for the Shopify App Store costs a one-time $19 fee per Partner account, and that registration isn't required at all if you're only building custom apps for a single merchant.

Once registered, a developer keeps 100% — a 0% revenue share — of their first $1,000,000 in lifetime gross App Store revenue, and pays 15% on everything earned above that threshold. Only revenue earned on or after January 1, 2025 counts toward the $1,000,000 figure, and the threshold is lifetime, not annual — it doesn't reset each year.

That 0% tier isn't automatic for every registered developer, though. It only applies if, in the prior calendar year, you earned less than $20,000,000 through the Shopify App Store and your company's gross revenue was under $100,000,000. Cross either threshold, and you pay 15% revenue share on all app revenue, with no 0% tier on the first million. An unregistered developer — one who skips registration and distributes a public app anyway — pays 20% of total revenue on that app from the first dollar, with no threshold at all. On top of revenue share, all billing carries a separate 2.9% processing fee plus applicable sales tax.

Most of this is invisible to the merchant paying for the app — their charges are billed through Shopify and show up on their Shopify bill either way. The exception is apps that charge merchants directly, outside Shopify's billing system; those charges don't appear on the Shopify bill at all, and a merchant has to track them separately with the app's developer. That's one more reason the custom app billing restriction matters in practice: a custom app's developer has to build and manage billing entirely outside Shopify from the start, rather than relying on Shopify to invoice on their behalf.

The Quality Bar and Lifecycle Obligations Either App Type Carries

Custom apps are built and managed through the Dev Dashboard, which tracks logs and health metrics and lets a developer test on a development store before deploying to the live one — the same kind of operational visibility a public app's developer gets, just scoped to a single store rather than a whole merchant base. One access-level detail worth knowing if a custom app needs broader data access: Custom Level 2 PII apps, which can read more sensitive personally identifiable information, require the store to be on the Grow plan or higher.

Distribution method aside, both custom and public apps live inside the same technical lifecycle. Shopify releases new API versions every three months, and each version keeps working for a year before it needs updating. If a version introduces a breaking change, Shopify notifies the app's developer, who then has nine months to update before the app becomes unsupported. Our guide to webhook health monitoring for custom apps covers how to track that from the Dev Dashboard so a version deprecation doesn't surface as a surprise outage.

Public apps carry one additional quality signal that custom apps don't: the Built for Shopify badge. It certifies three things specifically — the app can't decrease storefront speed by more than 10 performance points, it follows Shopify's admin design standards, and it uses Shopify's latest technology standards for admin compatibility. Shopify reviews these certifications annually, and an app that stops meeting them loses the badge. A custom app, built for one store and never listed, has no equivalent badge to earn or lose — but it's still subject to the same API version clock as every public app.

If you're weighing which of these fits your situation, talk to our team.

Frequently asked questions

What's the actual difference between a custom app and a public app on Shopify?

A custom app is built for one merchant — or multiple stores in the same Plus organization — needs no Shopify approval, and can't charge through Shopify's billing system. A public app can be installed on many unrelated stores, must pass Shopify's app review, and pays Shopify a share of its revenue.

Do custom apps need Shopify's approval before merchants can install them?

No. Custom distribution requires no approval from Shopify, which is one of the main reasons teams choose it for a single store's internal tooling.

Can a custom Shopify app charge merchants through Shopify billing?

No. A custom app can't use Shopify's app billing system to charge merchants, regardless of how many stores it's installed on. Apps that need to charge merchants through Shopify generally need public distribution instead.

How much of a public app's revenue does Shopify take?

A registered developer who qualifies for standard rates pays 0% on the first $1,000,000 in lifetime gross App Store revenue and 15% above that. Developers who exceed $20,000,000 in prior-year App Store revenue, or whose company revenue exceeds $100,000,000, pay 15% on all app revenue with no 0% tier. An unregistered developer pays 20% of total revenue from the first dollar.

Is there a fee to register as a Shopify App Store developer?

Yes, a one-time $19 fee per Partner account. Registration isn't required if you're only building custom apps for a single merchant, since custom distribution doesn't go through the Shopify App Store.

Sources

Tell us what you're building.

Share a few details and we'll reply within 1–2 business days with questions, a scope and a quote.