Shopify Email Marketing Tools: Email vs. Klaviyo
A size-based way to choose between Shopify Email and Klaviyo, using each platform's own current pricing and limits.

Shopify email marketing tools mostly come down to two choices: Shopify Email, which is free for up to 10,000 emails a month and built into the Shopify admin, and Klaviyo, a separate platform billed per active profile with deeper segmentation and branching automation. Which one fits depends mainly on your list size and how much lifecycle automation you actually need.
What Shopify Email actually costs
Shopify Email, delivered through Shopify Messaging, is available on the Basic, Grow, Advanced, and Plus plans. Every store gets 10,000 free emails to send at the start of each calendar month, shared across all campaigns sent that month — not 10,000 per campaign, and not a per-list allowance. Once you're past that, additional emails cost $1 USD per 1,000 up to 300,000 emails a month, drop to $0.65 USD per 1,000 after 300,000, and drop again to $0.55 USD per 1,000 after 750,000. You're not actually billed for those additional emails until the running cost reaches $0.005 USD, so a handful of overage sends won't show up as a line item on your bill. Shopify Messaging's built-in automations — welcome series, win-back, upsell — count toward that 10,000-email limit, but abandoned-checkout emails are always free and never count against it. Unused emails don't roll over to the next month, so there's no banking a quiet month's allowance to cover a busy one.
To make that concrete: a store that sends 12,000 emails across its campaigns in a month uses up the 10,000 free emails and pays for the remaining 2,000 at the $1-per-1,000 rate — a $2 charge, not a cliff where the whole month suddenly becomes expensive. That gradual, metered structure is part of why Shopify Email tends to stay inexpensive for stores that are still building their list; the cost only grows in proportion to how much you're actually sending, and the rate itself gets cheaper as volume climbs past 300,000 and 750,000 emails.
Because the automation templates ship inside the Shopify admin already, setting up the basics — welcome flows, abandoned-checkout follow-ups, win-back sequences — doesn't require picking a second platform first. For a small list, that free tier plus built-in templates is usually the cheapest way to get real lifecycle email running without evaluating a second vendor. If you want that automation layer built out properly rather than left on the default templates, that's the kind of work our Shopify automation service covers.
What Klaviyo actually costs
Klaviyo is a separate platform, not a Shopify-native tool, and its pricing is based on active profiles rather than email volume alone. The free plan covers up to 250 active profiles and 500 email sends a month. Once you outgrow that, the paid Email plan starts at $20 a month for 500 active profiles and 5,000 emails a month, with email-send capacity bundled into each profile tier rather than billed separately on top. Active profiles are the key unit here: any profile that can be emailed through Klaviyo counts, regardless of consent status, while profiles suppressed from email don't count toward the limit. A Marketing plan tier adds social marketing, reviews, and Customer Hub on top of the Email plan, priced by the same active-profile tiers, and a Custom plan exists for accounts over 150,000 active profiles.
The practical effect of profile-based billing is that your cost can climb even if you're not sending more email — simply growing your subscriber list past a tier boundary moves you to the next plan, independent of how many campaigns you actually send that month. That's a different cost curve from Shopify Email, where cost tracks email volume directly rather than list size. It also means the free plan's two limits work differently from each other: hitting the 500-email send cap stops sending until the next cycle or an upgrade, while exceeding 250 active profiles blocks sending until you either trim your profile count back down or move to a paid tier.
Where the two tools actually differ beyond price
Price aside, the two platforms are built around different defaults. Shopify Email ships with pre-built abandoned-checkout, browse-abandonment, and other automation templates already inside the Shopify admin, so the starting point is a working flow you tweak rather than a blank canvas. Klaviyo's billing is tied to both active profiles and emails sent, and your plan has to stay “profile-compliant”: if your active profile count exceeds your plan's tier at the end of a billing cycle, Klaviyo automatically moves your account to a larger, compliant plan for the next cycle. There's no manual opt-out of that upgrade — the only way to avoid it is reducing your active profile count below your current plan's limit before the cycle renews.
How to decide
None of this says one tool is better — it says they're sized for different problems, and the sizing comes from how each one bills rather than from a feature checklist. A few points worth weighing against your own numbers:
- If your list rarely sends past 10,000 emails in a calendar month, Shopify Email's free tier is the cheaper and simpler default, and the automation templates are already sitting in the admin waiting to be turned on.
- If your subscriber list has grown past a few hundred active profiles, Klaviyo's active-profile pricing becomes a real ongoing cost even before you touch its more advanced segmentation or branching flows.
- If you need multi-step conditional automation, deeper segmentation, or branching logic beyond what Shopify Messaging's templates offer, that capability gap is Klaviyo's main argument, separate from pricing entirely.
- The two aren't strictly either/or: it's reasonable to run Shopify Email for cost reasons on a small list while separately evaluating Klaviyo for one specific automation that Shopify Messaging doesn't support.
For the mechanics of setting up Shopify's own automation templates, see our guide to Shopify email automation, and for a worked example of one specific flow, see the Shopify abandoned-cart sequence that actually recovers sales.
If you want help setting up or auditing either platform's automations, talk to our team.
Frequently asked questions
Is Shopify Email really free?
Up to 10,000 emails a month, yes — shared across every campaign you send in that calendar month, on the Basic plan or higher. Past that limit, additional emails are billed per 1,000 at rates that drop as your volume grows, and you're not charged at all until the running cost for those extra emails reaches $0.005 USD.
Do abandoned checkout emails count against the free Shopify Email limit?
No. Shopify Messaging's automated abandoned-checkout emails are always free and don't count toward the 10,000-email monthly limit, even though other automation templates, like welcome or win-back series, do count toward it.
How does Klaviyo's active-profile pricing work?
Your plan is priced by how many active profiles you have — any profile that can be emailed through Klaviyo, regardless of consent status — plus the emails sent in a billing cycle. Profiles suppressed from email don't count toward your active-profile total.
What happens if Klaviyo active profiles exceed the plan's limit?
Klaviyo automatically moves your account to a profile-compliant plan for the next billing cycle. To avoid that automatic upgrade, you'd need to reduce your active profile count below your current plan's limit before the cycle renews.